Disagreement Over Research Unbundling Between UK and EU Fund Managers

As part of the regulatory framework enacted by MiFID II in January of 2018, asset managers were required to separate the cost of research from other costs such as trading commissions. This separation – or ‘unbundling’ – of costs is one of the most controversial changes brought about by MiFID, with detractors stating that it unfairly advantages larger firms. 

This controversy has been brought to light more sharply by the European Commissions recent review of MiFID II. As part of this review, citizens, NCAs and firms – particularly those from member states – were asked to make their feelings known about the efficacy of the regulations implemented as a result of MiFID II. The results of this review, which closed at Midnight on May 18th, have brought to light a clear divergence in opinion between the UK and the rest of the EU, leading to what The Financial Times has labelled a potential ‘early post-Brexit clash between UK and EU financial regulations’.

Prior to the implementation unbundling, the UK’s FCA (Financial Conduct Authority) was one of its biggest proponents. Other countries in the continental EU were more sceptical of the regulations, believing they would lead to a decrease in research quality.

The findings of the EC’s review of MiFID II have confirmed this scepticism. Fund managers in France and Germany whose assets account for over €9tn have used this review as an opportunity to push back against MiFID’s unbundling regulations.

The BVI – Germany’s fund association – has asked ESMA to ‘review the unbundling rules focusing on market practice’, as well as ‘how research costs are allocated’, particularly with reference to small- and medium-sized companies.

France’s AFG has mirrored this stance, arguing that the unbundling regulations put forward in MiFID II have led to a decrease in both the quantity and quality of investment research.

The UK, however, have argued the exact opposite. The Investment Association has claimed that any decline in research quantity is simply a result of unnecessary duplicate research not being produced by multiple providers. They have also claimed that no decrease in research quality has taken place as a result of unbundling.

The findings of the EC’s review have highlighted what could be the most significant post-Brexit change to European financial regulation. If Brussels accepts the arguments put forward by French and German fund managers while the UK holds fast to its present views on unbundling, we could see future clashes between the UK and ESMA’s European regulatory framework.


Best execution, market abuse and regulatory reporting solutions for financial services, and workflow management for any type of business. All powered by our PATH platform.

Quality Control: Is Sampling Effective in Transaction Reporting?

Quality Control: Is Sampling Effective in Transaction Reporting?Ben Parker, CEO and FounderlinkedintwitterFinancial firms face a complex web of regulatory requirements – with transaction reporting undoubtedly taking the crown as one of the most challenging. Firms need...

Regulatory Responses to Algorithmic Trading

Recent events have pushed algorithmic trading to the front of the financial regulatory agenda. We consider what this might mean for automated trading.

David vs. Goliath or Market Abuse? The Regulatory Challenge Posed by GameStop

David vs. Goliath or Market Abuse? - The Regulatory Challenge Posed by GameStopBen Parker, CEO and FounderlinkedintwitterA New Regulatory Challenge Global financial regulators are eyeing up new controls on market manipulation following the widely reported GameStop...

UK, MAR and Market Abuse After Brexit – The New Regime Explained

The UK, MAR and Market Abuse After Brexit - The New Regime ExplainedDouglas Moffat, New Business ExecutivelinkedintwitterMAR and Market Abuse After Brexit Market abuse is a serious concern for financial regulators. It’s why the European Union sought to further codify...

Technology, Compliance & COVID: The 2021 Thomson Reuters Regulatory Report

Technology, Compliance & COVID 19: Unwrapping Thompson Reuters’ 2021 Report on FinTech, RegTech and the Role of Compliance Ben Parker, Director and Founder linkedintwitterAn increased reliance on technology, continued investment in compliance, and predictably...

Get In Touch

[contact-form-7 id="26302" title="AMP Form 2"]